Laevatein: Hey everyone, welcome back to our Sai Mecha 2012 coverage! As usual, you can see the results of this round here, and you can see our Earth Side, Round 2 coverage here. Kaushik here is returning once again. So let’s start off with this particularly exciting round.
Turn A Gundam vs Black Getter (66.67% vs 33.33%)
Kaushik: So for this first round we have two heavyweights, the Turn A Gundam from Turn A Gundam, and Black Getter from Getter Robo Armageddon. The Turn A wins quite handily at 66 to Black Getter’s 33, and I suppose I shouldn’t be too surprised.
Laevatein: There goes Getter.
Kaushik: Yeah, Turn A was just more popular, I guess.
Laevatein: Well, I voted for Turn A, as usual, as I fucking love Turn A. Anyway, I guess it’s impossible to argue that the Turn A is hated nowadays.
Kaushik: Yeah it’s been doing pretty well. Sad to see Black Getter go but it lost to a pretty strong competitor.
Laevatein: Agreed, guess there goes the dark horse of the tournament. Anyway, next!
TIE: Gouf Custom vs GP-03 Dendrobium (50% vs 50%) Sudden death results below.
Kaushik: Another tie this week, between the Gouf Custom and the GP-03 Dendrobium. Two older machines, and… I’m not sure what to think of this matchup. I don’t have particularly strong feelings for either of the mechs.
Laevatein: Both are classics in their own way, though.
Kaushik: Yeah I suppose they’re classics. I’m not even sure I’m surprised they tied. I guess I thought the Dendrobium would have won since it’s a protagonist mech, but the Gouf Custom is more popular than I realized.
Laevatein: Well, 0083 gets a decent amount of hate.
Kaushik: I do like the Dendrobium’s design, though. Back in the days where, to fit a shit ton of weapons on, you’d have to put a lot of shit on your machine.
Laevatein: Dendrobium also happens to be one of the only “siege” mechs that a protagonist in a Gundam series gets. Well, the siege part is an extension. But uh, interesting way of resolving that tie, huh?
Kaushik: Yeah, it was certainly a unique way to go about it.
Laevatein: I probably would’ve gone with a Googlefight or something, haha.
Kaushik: I probably would’ve been more concerned if it were a matchup I cared about, but it was alright to resolve this one this way.
Laevatein: Well, at least it was close right to the bitter end. Homura really stood her ground, hahaha. Anyway, next up!
Gunbuster vs Gao Gai Gar (58.59% vs 41.41%)
Kaushik: A battle of some titanic supers this time, Gunbuster vs. Gao Gai Gar. Gunbuster pulls this one, though it’s a pretty good fight, 58 to 41. Definitely a fan of the Gunbuster here.
Laevatein: Yeah, I voted for GaoGaiGar, but this was no surprise. Gunbuster was much more influential than GaoGaiGar, whereas GaoGaiGar was, unfortunately, just a really good classic. Still, I think this might be the saddest round for me.
Kaushik: I definitely love both of the machines here, but I don’t think Gao Gai Gar is any competition for the Gunbuster. The Gunbuster came first, and it’s not leaving anytime soon.
Laevatein: It might even wind up in GARhalla, if things turn out well for it. Anyway, time for the final match of this round!
Escaflowne vs Kshatriya (43.93% vs 56.07%)
Kaushik: The Escaflowne vs. the Kshatriya… the Kshatriya takes this in the closest match this round (other than the tie of course) 43 to 56. I’ve never really seen Escaflowne so I don’t know too much about it. Based on that flawed reasoning my vote goes for the Kshatriya, but to be honest I’m not a huge fan of the Kshatriya either.
Laevatein: Well, Escaflowne is unique for being one of the few magic mechs. But, well, I gave it to the Kshatriya. I don’t really know why. It’s pretty cool, what with all those funnels, I guess.
Kaushik: Funnels don’t really impress me anymore. No one will ever do them better than the Nu Gundam anyway.
Laevatein: There’s that, but funnels are still inherently interesting. Still, I don’t see this one lasting for too much longer. Anyway, time for the bonus round!
K-ON: K-00n Gitah Memories (25.51%) Kimi ni Todoke: Kisama ni Todoke (6.12%) vsPrince of Tennis: Aim for the Ball! PuriTeni! (25.51%) vs Hidamari Sketch: Super Dimensional Fortress Hidamarisou (17.35%) vs Maria-sama ga Miteru: Mecha-sama Watches Over Us (25.51%)
Kaushik: Well here we have a battle between which series would benefit the most from mecha elements, and we have a 3 way tie. The winners are K-ON: K-00n Gitah Memories, Prince of Tennis: Aim for the Ball! PuriTeni!, and Maria-sama ga Miteru: Mecha-sama Watches Over Us. I don’t think any of these could really benefit from mecha elements, but I thought Kimi ni Todoke: Kisama ni Todoke was the funniest, just because how opposed the idea of Kimi ni Todoke and mecha are. It seems to have gotten the least amount of votes though… I don’t think many mecha fans care for Kimi ni Todoke, too bad.
Laevatein: Well, I thought Prince of Tennis was a natural fit, what with that dinosaur-ending special in the movie.
Kaushik: Yeah, there is that.
Laevatein: Can’t get any more mecha than extinction, I suppose.
Laevatein: Anyway, that’s it for this round. Be sure to vote in MidGAR!
Latest posts by Laevatein (see all)
- Review: Legend of the Legendary Heroes - August 30, 2014
- Review: Black Lagoon – Roberta’s Blood Trail - August 25, 2014
- Mecha Monday: Aldnoah.Zero Impressions - July 28, 2014
- Mecha Monday: Shirogane no Ishi Argevollen Impressions - July 21, 2014
- Mecha Monday: Mecha at E3 2014 - June 16, 2014